Inside the Private Pet Groups Driving Big Repeat Sales

Issue #213

July 8th, 2025

Quick Hits:

💉 US pet owners have a growing concern about vaccines giving their pets autism

🐑 BTS clips of working dogs in Patagonia that help move livestock

🫨 This might be the fastest Dachshund we’ve ever seen

🤝 Inspired Pet Nutrition is acquiring Sopral, a dry pet food company based in France

🌐 Native Pet continues expansion with its’ launch at Pet Supplies Plus

CPMs on Meta ads for some brands rose by as much as 100% YoY in 2024, squeezing margins for DTC pet brands that still rely on spray-and-pray social campaigns.

Yet a quieter, cheaper growth lever is hiding in plain sight: private online communities. According to Circle's 2025 Community Trends Report, just one single engaged community member drives roughly the same business value as 234 public-social followers.

👆️ _{Napkin math: Recallers has 4K members (let’s assume every member only subbed 1x @$767), that would be +$3M in lifetime revenue.}

_{This group is ~8yrs old so that would be $380K/yr in revenue generated from this private community since inception.}

For founders, marketers, and operators in the pet space, that math is hard to ignore. Instead of chasing ever-pricier impressions, many businesses are funneling their most passionate customers into invite-only Facebook Groups, Discord servers, Skool communities, Slack, breed clubs, and support circles.

These are spaces where trust runs deep and repeat purchases feel natural. In other words, the power play for 2025 isn't a bigger follower count; it's a smaller, stickier circle.

Why Private Groups Are Pure Gold for Pet Brands

Picture this: You're a reactive dog owner. Would you rather ask for help on a public Facebook page or sub Reddit where keyboard warriors might shame your "poorly trained" pup, or in a closed support group where fellow struggling dog parents actually get it?

The answer is obvious - and that's exactly why private communities work.

Trust and candor reign supreme. Pet owners feel safer asking sensitive or "silly" questions in closed groups. Members of online communities report they get more meaningful conversation and feel more respected and "heard" than on open social media. A reactive dog owner might hesitate to post about her struggles publicly, but in a closed support circle she'll open up and welcome guidance from both peers and brands.

Loyalty gets a major boost. When people feel seen and valued in a group, they keep coming back (and keep buying). A survey of 400+ companies found that 74.5% of consumers feel more valued as customers when they have access to an online community. Not surprisingly, 60% are more loyal to the brand because of that community access. These loyal members often become repeat buyers - and even a small lift in retention can yield huge gains. A 5% increase in customer retention can boost profits by up to 95%.

User-generated content flows like water. Niche groups naturally produce a stream of testimonials, training tips, and "Fido loves your product" photos. Engagement in these groups is dramatically higher than on typical social feeds: one industry report found only ~0.5–5% of followers engage on brand social media, versus nearly 50% of members actively engaged in online communities. In other words, a small private group can be a hive of activity and ideas, plus a built-in focus group where you can float product ideas and instantly get feedback.

Finally, consider sheer scale: Facebook reports over 1.8 billion people use Groups every month - a massive portion of the online world now convenes in private spaces. Pet and breed groups are among the most active. There are canine communities with hundreds of thousands of members (the popular "Dogspotting" Facebook group boasts about 1.9 million dog-loving members. Pet owners are flocking to these niche communities, finding more value in a closed circle of fellow enthusiasts than in the noise of public feeds.

Real Examples That Actually Move the Needle

Let me show you how this plays out in dollars and cents:

Dog Sports Training Communities: Denise Fenzi's dog sports academy uses private Facebook groups as a core part of its offering. Students who enroll in online courses get access to closed groups where instructors and peers provide ongoing support. This isn't just a nicety - it's a subscription model powered by community. Alumni stick around for "lifetime" learning and often purchase new courses thanks to the group's encouragement. As one member describes, the FDSA Facebook group is "a very positive Facebook retreat" where trainers regularly interact, share training videos, and keep students engaged. The community itself becomes a product, fueling recurring revenue through subscriptions and upsells.

Reactive Dog Support Circles: Trainer Ulrika Marwick's Reactive Dogs Club bundles a step-by-step course with a Facebook support community of fellow dog owners. Members pay for access to training modules and the private group, where they celebrate wins ("We passed 8 dogs calmly today!") and hold each other accountable. The peer support keeps them subscribed and progressing, and Marwick adds value with live Q&As in the group. Classic membership flywheel: community drives retention, which drives repeat revenue.

Brand Channels: Bella & Duke’s “Pack”

Bella & Duke, a U.K. raw-feeding subscription brand, started life as a small raw-feeding Facebook group. That private circle, now branded “The Pack”, has grown into more than 32,000 members who post daily “bowl pics,” health wins, and features a pet of the week from the community in their cover image. In a 2019 brand video Bella & Duke notes that “what began as a small raw-feeding Facebook group has blossomed into a 22,000-strong community of pet parents dedicated to improving the health and happiness of their dogs.”

How the community converts:

• Always-on UGC engine. The Pack’s before/after coat shots and feeding videos become ready-made creative for ads, email, and product pages—saving the brand on production costs.

• Retention moat. Peer accountability (and FOMO when other Pack members share progress) helps keep subscription churn low; customers who consider cancelling often stay after reading success stories from owners of similar breeds.

The Playbook: How to Do This Right

Build Your Own vs. Partner Wisely: If a thriving independent group already exists for your niche (like a 50K-member "Doodle Owners" group), it might be better to partner and become a valued contributor rather than splitting the audience. If you have a distinct brand voice or education to offer, building your own private group gives you control. Either way, contribute genuine value before ever mentioning your product.

Moderate Like Your Business Depends on It: The fastest way to kill a community is to let it turn into a spam-fest. Quality over quantity is the mantra. Active moderation is key: remove spam posts, fact-check misinformation (especially important in pet health groups), and keep the conversation useful. Focus on being a facilitator of value - advice, tips, insider info, exclusive content - not just a promoter.

Use Groups as Informal Focus Groups: Private communities can double as R&D labs. You can float ideas, run quick polls, or solicit unfiltered feedback faster and cheaper than formal market research.

What Not to Do (Learn from Others' Mistakes)

Over-monetizing kills the vibe. If members feel like the group exists just to squeeze dollars out of them, the community's spirit will wither. Pet parents join groups to get help, camaraderie, and authentic connection not to be bombarded with "BUY NOW" posts or bludgeoned with repetitive discounts. Earn the right to sell by delivering value first. Prioritize the relationship over immediate revenue. Ironically, this approach leads to more revenue in the long run. Don’t come across as a pushy used car salesman.

Neglecting moderation derails everything. Unchecked spam, trollish behavior, or misinformation will drive away the very members you want to keep. Set clear guidelines and enforce them fairly. The best groups often have a personal touch from founders or moderators that reinforces the values of the space.

Your Next Move

Private pet communities aren't just "nice-to-have" side projects, they're loyalty engines and innovation labs rolled into one. The insights and loyalty nurtured in a 500-person breed forum can easily outweigh the engagement from 50,000 passive Instagram followers.

To brainstorm your approach, ask yourself: "What would my highest-value customers pay to learn, share, or feel connected about?" The answer could hint at your next community offering. Don't be afraid to start small and niche, the strongest loyalty often comes from these micro-engagements.

Searches for “dog pancreatitis” have jumped 20% in the past year - topping 138K queries last month alone. That steady five-year climb shows more dog owners are looking for help with a condition that can be tricky (and scary) to manage at home. The search line also hints that people aren’t finding clear, trusted guidance in one place. They’re bouncing between Dr. Google, FB groups, and vet Q&As.

For pet brands, clinics, and nutrition pros, this is a signal worth acting on. Whether you sell prescription diets, supplements, or just education, there’s growing demand for credible, easy-to-understand content on what causes canine pancreatitis, how to spot it early, and how to feed for recovery. A private community or resource hub for owners managing flare-ups could build serious trust in a category that’s clearly under-served online.

You reached the end, you deserve a treat 🍖

Be part of the pack - For more news, links, and entertainment, follow us on social media (links below) and fur - ward this to your best human friend.

See you Friday!